Participatory evaluation. Abstract. Participatory evaluation is presented as...

Evaluators, emerging and experienced alike, lament on how difficult

Use of Participatory Tools for Monitoring and Evaluation The use of participatory tools in project planning is widespread and common. As project planners, we might gather with potential project participants to do a card or other sorting exercise, or create a seasonal calendar, for example. We can integrate these into our project planning, when ...This focus on participatory and community-engaged research is one component of our larger efforts to apply an equity lens to our research and evaluation work. We know that the research process itself can perpetuate or can reduce inequity by choices made implicitly or explicitly about the questions asked; who is viewed as an expert; and the ...• Evaluation should be a structured and planned process based on clear performance criteria, goals and desired outcomes and carried out systematically using appropriate methods, as opposed to relying on assumptions and/or informal feedback. • Evaluation should, whenever possible, be a participatory activity involving keyParticipatory action research (PAR) is an approach to research that prioritizes the value of experiential knowledge for tackling problems caused by unequal and harmful social systems, and for ...Participatory evaluation of a quality improvement collaborative Patient Safety Collaboratives In 2014, NHS England commissioned 15 Patient Safety Collaboratives hosted by Academic Health Science Networks to deliver safety improvement in response to Professor Don Berwick's report A Promise to Learn—aIn today’s digital age, it is easier than ever to research and evaluate companies before making a purchasing decision. One valuable resource that consumers can rely on is the Better Business Bureau (BBB).participatory evaluation are also explored. Two participatory evaluation case examples are presented in Chap-ters 6 and 7. Chapter 6 describes the use of a participatory evaluation approach to evaluate a community health improvement initiative, focus - ing on heart disease and Type 2 diabetes. There are over 1.5 million heart attacks each year.Participation of all parties concerned in the entire process: An evaluation needs to be as participatory as possible (e.g. developing jointly the Terms of Reference with the project partners, the possibility of all parties involved to comment on the results or the evaluation report).Participatory Monitoring and Evaluation P-PE and T-PE are usually episodic, evaluating a given programme, initiative or policy, and are time delimited. PME, however, conceptualizes evaluation as ongoing, an evolving process of question asking, data collection and action.It draws on the available literature, including our own participatory evaluation of a project intended to increase youth participation in organizational development and community change. Get full access to this article. View all access and purchase options for this article.The study explores the meaning of youth participatory evaluation and examines the challenges faced in utilizing the approach. We argue that using digital technology can help overcome many challenges of youth participatory evaluations, with the added benefit that such technology may also attract and influence young people to engage more fully ...Participatory design is an approach to design strategy that brings customers into the heart of the design process. Also known as “co-creation”, “co-design”, or “cooperative design”, it emcompasses techniques useful to both initial discovery and subsequent ideation phases of a project, where the end-users of a product, service, or ...• Evaluation should be a structured and planned process based on clear performance criteria, goals and desired outcomes and carried out systematically using appropriate methods, as opposed to relying on assumptions and/or informal feedback. • Evaluation should, whenever possible, be a participatory activity involving keyevaluation from the same perspective can help achieve this goal. Over the past 50+ years, a range of participatory frameworks—including Arnsteins’ ladder of civic participation and participatory rural appraisals’ levels of participatory learning—have sought to categorize aspects of participatory evaluation as more or less participatory. 4Participatory evaluation enables users of services to take part in designing and implementing the evaluation of those services. The style and values of the organization and the programs being evaluated will determine who participates in the process. A flatter, more inclusive organization is likely to include more people in the evaluation process.This guide introduces the rationale for participatory evaluations and presents some broad guidelines for facilitating them. It discusses why planners should consider participatory evaluation and how to go about making this approach work to the best advantage. The first section gives some background to the concept of involving beneficiaries in different phases of project management, and reviews ...Participatory evaluation. This type of evaluation is conducted collaboratively with the beneficiaries, key stakeholders and partners to improve the project implementation. Participatory evaluation can be empowering for everyone involved as it builds capacity, consensus, ownership, credibility and joint support.A good example for such a strategy is the online data collection and monitoring system for New Mexico's Community Health Councils (USA), which was developed collectively by applying a participatory evaluation design. The result is a system which has relevance for both public health professionals and the wider community . Participatory ...Participatory Approaches to Evaluation Lori Bakken, MS, PhD Professor, School of Human Ecology, Civil Society and Community Studies Evaluation Specialist, Division of Extension Learning Objectives Describe participatory approaches and how they differ from other approaches to evaluation.• Evaluation should be a structured and planned process based on clear performance criteria, goals and desired outcomes and carried out systematically using appropriate methods, as opposed to relying on assumptions and/or informal feedback. • Evaluation should, whenever possible, be a participatory activity involving keyConventional M&E and can be differentiated from participatory M&E in terms of three parameters: 1. Involvement and role of stakeholders and rights holders. In these two approaches, the roles and responsibilities of people involved are somewhat different. In conventional M&E, senior managers, outside experts, and/or donor agencies typically ...Innovative Citizen Participation. Innovative Citizen Participation explores the innovative ways that governments can effectively engage with citizens and stakeholders to source ideas, co-create solutions, and tackle complex policy problems. It focuses on new research in the area of deliberative, collaborative, and participatory decision making ...Advocacy Evaluation Training Pack.3 Another popular approach is known as participatory program evaluation. This approach involves external stakeholders who monitor and evaluate your activities, rather than merely relying solely on internal M&E. A number of resources discuss participatory M&E, and these are listed in the Additional Resources ...Importance of evaluation in participatory research. Traditionally, most research is evaluated at the end of a study by using quantitative methods to objectively assess the process, effectiveness or impact of a new program or intervention (52). However, outcomes of participatory research are integrated in the process and might occur at any stage ...Using a participatory evaluation approach allows for the mutual alignment of priorities and timelines between implementers, target clients, and community members. It also aligns those critical parameters that define project success with the client's perspective. So, to design our evaluation in an inclusive way, we have done extensive ...Abstract. In this study evaluation methodology is discussed in the context of a participatory community health development project. The paper presents a study of the participatory dynamics of the project and explores the implications thereof for the evaluation of participation. The principal source of data is interviews conducted with 13 ...This report describes a participatory evaluation of a postgraduate course delivered at the University of Winchester in the UK. The PGCert/MA in Student Engagement in Higher Education utilized ...Interviews. Interviews are conversations between an investigator (interviewer) and a respondent (‘interviewees’, ‘informants’ or ‘sources’) in which questions are asked in order to obtain information. Interviews seek to collect data and narrative information in order to better understand the respondent’s unique perspectives ...The process of participatory evaluation planning. Engage stakeholders. Define the purpose of the evaluation. Describe the program: shared understanding, narrative description, logic model, stages ...by participatory evaluation. In this case, a standard model may be more effective. The participatory model provides an opportunity for critical self-assessment, which can be used to improve the program. It is the level of commitment to self-assessment and program improvement, therefore, that determines the success of the evaluation.Using participatory approaches in impact evaluation means involving stakeholders, particularly the participants in a programme or those affected by a given policy, in specific aspects of the evaluation process. The term covers a wide range of different types of participation and stakeholders can be involved in any stage of the impact evaluation …Participatory Evaluation, Demonstration and Popularization of Improved Sweet Potato, Ipomea Batatas L. Varieties in Middle Awash, Afar Region November 2022 Advances in Crop Science and Technology ...A participatory evaluation committee requires a clear structure and operational process to function most effectively. This can begin with a thorough training and orientation in the participatory evaluation process. Without this foundation, members of the evaluation committee may waiver from the group's agreed purpose before getting on board ...Results: Participatory governance and co-production are well aligned to the principles of MAE (Made in Africa Evaluation) and may provide the means to arriving at more inclusive forms of ME ...A participatory learning approach, applied at each stage of a community development project, is crucial to reaching the level of stakeholder involvement needed for lasting, positive change. The use of participatory survey and planning methods in the development process encourages community ownership of projects, allows for information toBy practicing Youth Participatory Evaluation (YPE), evaluation is no longer just a task on their to-do list, it is a way for youth and adults to collaboratively assess and guide the program. The Youth Leadership Initiative has practiced YPE for almost five years. They believe in YPE because they've witnessed its benefits for youth, adults ...Participatory evaluation can help improve program performance by (1) involving key stakeholders in evaluation design and decision making, (2) acknowledging and addressing asymmetrical levels of power and voice …Evaluation should be practical and feasible and conducted within the confines of resources, time, and political context. Moreover, it should serve a useful purpose, be conducted in an ethical manner, and produce accurate findings. Evaluation findings should be used both to make decisions about program implementation and to improve program ...Practical-participatory evaluation is often considered an effective approach to enhancing evaluation use. Despite this generally positive connotation, potential negative effects of participatory evaluation have also been discussed in the literature but never empirically investigated before.Education. Participatory Monitoring and Evaluation background, concepts and principles, goals of PM&E, the PM&E process, stakeholder analysis, PM&E framework, plan, worksheet, a case study using PM&E. Len Fontanilla Follow. Aquaculturist I at Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources.A sports physical is an examination. Most schools, camps and organizations require a sports physical before your child can participate in sports and other physical activities. Healthcare providers also call this exam a pre-participation physical evaluation (PPE). During a sports physical, your healthcare provider examines your child.Participatory Monitoring and Evaluation There are various purposes and advantages of a participatory M&E approach, many of which are already mentioned here: " Participation in South Africa ". In a participatory M&E process, community members become active planners, decision-makers and actors.In the fast-paced and ever-evolving healthcare industry, it is crucial for healthcare organizations to have an effective system in place to evaluate the performance of their nursing staff.This publication showcases good and promising practices on gender-responsive evaluation approaches and methods by featuring gender-responsive evaluations from UN Women and UN entities. It also highlights the important role of country-led evaluations of National Gender Equality Strategies and Actions Plans in building national evaluation capacity …Participatory evaluation: Going beyond the rhetoric Although 'empowerment' is a prominent value in the field of international development, attempts to monitor and measure it have largely relied on indicators determined by external people for external use. These approaches assumed that people's own assessments would be too simpleLearner participation is needed for Curriculum for Excellence’s aims and purposes to be achieved across all contexts of learning. Learner participation is a key thread ... and evaluate on how all arenas of school and early years life can better support learner participation. We must help young people understand and exercise their rightsHowever, very limited research that explores the use of photography for youth participatory evaluation in the context of health promotion/prevention programming exists. Thus, the purpose of this project was to develop and explore the use of a participatory, photo-based evaluation method for health promotion/prevention programming with adolescents.Participatory evaluation. This type of evaluation is conducted collaboratively with the beneficiaries, key stakeholders and partners to improve the project implementation. Participatory evaluation can be empowering for everyone involved as it builds capacity, consensus, ownership, credibility and joint support.Monitoring and evaluation are two separate, but interrelated strategies to collect data and report the findings on how well (or not) the policy, program, or project is performing. Monitoring is a process that involves, collecting the data about implementation, checking theThere are two main types of loans: personal and business. Business loans are processed as either corporate or commercial depending on the amount, however, they both call for a rigorous approval process in order to pass the risk manager's as...Conclusions: This research provides support for the importance of an early-stage participatory evaluation of beneficiaries' perceptions of newly initiated health programmes. Our results support how evaluations conducted in the early phases of programme implementation can provide valuable, timely feedback as well as yield recommendations for ...Community-based participatory research (CBPR) approaches present strong opportunities to promote health equity by improving health within low-income communities and communities of color. CBPR principles and evaluation frameworks highlight an emphasis on equitable group dynamics (e.g., shared leaders …It is our belief that when CBOs establish participatory research and evaluation as a core part of their practice, they protect the quality of their work with their communities in a way that builds credibility, power, and influence with other stakeholders, including funders. Perhaps most importantly, it builds effectiveness.The following is a discussion of process evaluation techniques that are used by CoC grantees. Participant Observation Though there is a range of participatory roles that evaluators can play that run the gamut from fully immersed and invisible participant to fly on the wall sidelines observer, the common experience of CoC grantees is toAbstract. Participatory evaluation is presented as an extension of the stakeholder-based model with a focus on enhancing evaluation utilization through primary users' increased depth and range of participation in the applied research process. The approach is briefly described and then justified from theoretical and empirical bases.PARTICIPATORY EVALUATION. a form of program assessment wherein the people who rendered a service also have a part in the assessment of the program or …Impact " Most of the time the outside experts fly in and out without taking the time to listen to the people. In this evaluation they really listened to us and respected our opinions-we all worked together to make the project stronger. "-Local participant, Honduras forestry project evaluation Participatory Monitoring and Evaluation (PME) offers development organizations a host of …participatory approaches used in three projects in Leon County (Florida) schools are described. The first section of the paper provides a rationale for the contents of the checklist derived from extant professional evaluation standards and participatory evaluation literature. The second section is devoted to applying the checklistevaluation from the same perspective can help achieve this goal. Over the past 50+ years, a range of participatory frameworks—including Arnsteins' ladder of civic participation and participatory rural appraisals' levels of participatory learning—have sought to categorize aspects of participatory evaluation as more or less participatory. 4Impact " Most of the time the outside experts fly in and out without taking the time to listen to the people. In this evaluation they really listened to us and respected our opinions-we all worked together to make the project stronger. "-Local participant, Honduras forestry project evaluation Participatory Monitoring and Evaluation (PME) offers development organizations a host of …Participatory evaluation is a designed approach that engages . participants in the process. The distinguishing characteristic of . participatory evaluation is its reliance on non-evaluator ...1. Introduction Participatory evaluation (PE) is a collaborative inquiry process among the emerging and innovative evaluation approaches such as collaborative, democratic-deliberative, empowerment, fourth-generation, inclusive and utilization-focused, explicitly endorsing the principle of stakeholder participation (Daigneault, Jacob, & Tremblay ...The participatory process involved community partners and academicians in a fluid process to identify common ground activities and outcomes. The logic model, a lay friendly approach, was used as the template and clearly outlined the steps to be taken in the evaluation process without sacrificing the rigorousness of the evaluation process.Participatory evaluation is presented as an extension of the stakeholder-based model with a focus on enhancing evaluation utilization through primary users’ increased depth and range of participation in the applied research process. The approach is briefly described and then justified from theoretical and empirical bases. The literature on organizational learning provides theoretical support ...Self-evaluation corresponds to the paradigm of emancipatory evaluation that, according to , "has its construction inspired by three theoretical-methodological strands: the first one is defined as democratic evaluation; the second is the institutional critique and collective creation; and the third is participatory research" [7, 8]. In the ...Further, although mixed-method and participatory approaches that engage stakeholders are recommended, few studies have incorporated these strategies [10,18,19]. Participatory needs assessment represents a promising evaluation approach for proactive identification of, and response to, the needs of CTR stakeholders [20,21].Participatory evaluation up close: A review and integration of the research base. Information Age Press. Google Scholar. Cousins J. B., Leithwood K. A. (1986). Current empirical research on evaluation utilization. Review of Educational Research, 56(3), 331–364. Crossref. ISI.The following participatory methods and tools, which can be used to encourage community member participation in program activities, are drawn from MEAS Participatory Methods and Tools for Extension documents. Rapid Rural Appraisal (RRA) Rapid Rural Appraisal (RRA) is not one tool but a range of evaluation approaches.research methods: RRA (Rapid Rural Appraisal) and PRA (Participatory Rural Appraisal). As noted in the sections that follow, these methods are participatory and qualitative and are especially valuable in gathering information that will provide insights about people and the communities in which they live. These insights will, in turn, enableConclusions: This research provides support for the importance of an early-stage participatory evaluation of beneficiaries' perceptions of newly initiated health programmes. Our results support how evaluations conducted in the early phases of programme implementation can provide valuable, timely feedback as well as yield recommendations for ...Monitoring and evaluation (M&E) of development activities provides government officials, development managers, and civil society with better means for learning from past experience, improving service delivery, planning and allocating resources, and demonstrating results as part of accountability to key stakeholders.Community‐based participatory research (CBPR) is an approach to health and environmental research meant to increase the value of studies for both researchers and the community being studied. This approach is particularly attractive for academics and public health professionals struggling to address the persistent problems of health care …Resources. Stakeholder participation in monitoring and evaluation. PDF. 95.49 KB. This tool from the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) provides an overview of the process of participatory monitoring. The paper includes a step by step process and a number of case study examples to demonstrate the specifics of the approach.Participatory evaluation is a process in which evaluation experts and members of a community who are not experts in evaluation evaluate community actions or projects jointly and on the same level. Participatory evaluation is a community development strategy. In this paper, we analyse the relationship between participatory evaluation and ...Participatory evaluation can help improve program performance by (1) involving key stakeholders in evaluation design and decision making, (2) acknowledging and addressing asymmetrical levels of power and voice among stakeholders, (3) using multiple and varied methods, (4) having an action component so that evaluation findings are useful to the p...Employee self-evaluations are an important tool for both employees and employers. They provide an opportunity for employees to reflect on their own performance, set goals, and identify areas for improvement.The new edition of Community-Based Participatory Research for Health by Nina Wallerstein and colleagues is an extremely valuable resource for a wide variety of stakeholders interested in collaborative work to promote health equity. This updated collection succinctly delineates the theory, history, principles, and practices of community-based participatory research (CBPR) to help the reader ...Practical-participatory evaluation is often considered an effective approach to enhancing evaluation use. Despite this generally positive connotation, potential negative effects of participatory evaluation have also been discussed in the literature but never empirically investigated before.. Participatory evaluation has been developedEvaluation team develops the final design, collects data, an The definitive guide to CBPR concepts and practice, updated and expanded Community-Based Participatory Research for Health: Advancing Health and Social Equity provides a comprehensive reference for this rapidly growing field in participatory and community-engaged research. Hailed as effective by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, CBPR and CEnR represent the link between ...In contrast, youth participatory evaluation is an approach that engages young people in key decision-making within the evaluation process . Involving youth peer supporters in research co-design strengthens impact through the inclusion of the lived experience of the client and service provider perspectives . One peer from the LOFT Transitional ... Participatory evaluation has been developed collectively i A participatory approach requires time and commitment from 2 Guiding Principles of Participatory Evaluation Participant focus and ownership - Structures and process-es are created to include those most frequently powerless or voiceless in program design and implementation. The participatory process honors human contributions and cul-tural ... Evaluators, emerging and experienced alike, lament on how...

Continue Reading